[irvingpop]

Records the production release of the summary comment redesign (PR #12) as decision P3-7.

• Release SHA: 9e2795b (main). Unit tests passed; release evals 13/13 (run 40713029193).
• Owner edited Console rule claude-review-prod-r1 to the new SHA. Test ruleset pin moved from M3 to 9e2795b and read back.
• Live checks in claude-review-test: a pass (PR 28, run 40713506554) and a fail with a hard block (PR 40, run 40713856249), both in the new layout.
• Deviations: R1 edited in place (no new rule), and the denied exchange before the Console edit was not run.

Docs only. Reviewed against the release facts before push.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

[github-actions]

🔴 FAIL: OC Claude review did not complete

Caution

The Review, Security and Supply chain reviews did not run, so this PR could not be judged. No waiver can clear this.
Next step: a maintainer re-runs the newest run of the required workflow once the cause is fixed. The author does not need to change anything.

Severity	Effect	Where	Finding	Found by
⚠️ Not run	Blocks, no waiver	Review pass	authentication failed. The pass returned no result.	Workflow (code, no model)
⚠️ Not run	Blocks, no waiver	Security pass	authentication failed. The pass returned no result.	Workflow (code, no model)
⚠️ Not run	Blocks, no waiver	Supply chain pass	authentication failed. The pass returned no result.	Workflow (code, no model)
⚠️ Not run	Blocks, no waiver	Gate	A required job did not succeed: dependency-review: failure	Workflow (code, no model)
⚠️ Not run	Blocks, no waiver	Gate	Dependency review did not succeed: job result failure	Workflow (code, no model)
⚠️ Not run	Blocks, no waiver	Gate	Dependency review did not succeed: step outcome failure	Workflow (code, no model)

File checks	Review	Security	Supply chain	Dependency review	Coverage
✅ ok, 2 signals	❌ failed	❌ failed	❌ failed	❌ failed	✅ complete

_{Run 40714578433, attempt 1 for head cc2ca39 into main. The required workflow in the merge box is the result that counts. This bot never approves a PR.}

📋 Full review record: reasons, checks, signals, finding details, model summaries, token usage

Reviewed snapshot

Head SHA	Merge base SHA	Base branch	Run
cc2ca39b920c431edfc179d479977290ce463c76	9e2795b97b22869b9e5c7a777e71a2afa8366eeb	main	40714578433, attempt 1

Reasons the gate failed

Reason	Waivable?	Detail
A required job did not succeed	🚫 no	dependency-review: failure
Dependency review did not succeed	🚫 no	job result failure
Dependency review did not succeed	🚫 no	step outcome failure
A review pass failed	🚫 no	pass review failed: authentication failed
A review pass failed	🚫 no	pass security failed: authentication failed
A review pass failed	🚫 no	pass supply-chain failed: authentication failed

No waiver line is shown. At least one reason cannot be waived, so a waiver would not change the result.

Checks (code, no model)

Check	Result	Detail
Hard blocks	✅ none
Coverage	✅ complete	files in comparison 2, files collected 2, trees complete
Dependency changes	✅ none
Dependency review job	❌ failed

Signals (context only, never block)

• ℹ️ Text aimed at an AI reviewer: pattern ai-reviewer, in docs/claude-review-design.md, lines 987
• ℹ️ Very long line: lines longer than 500 characters, in docs/claude-review-design.md, lines 987

Dependency changes

None.

Finding details

Model output from untrusted input. Check it before you act on it. Verified means only that the quoted text is at that place. It does not mean the claim is true.

Blocking is decided by code from category and severity, never by the model. A finding in a blocking category blocks only at high or critical severity.

No findings from the passes that ran. The Review, Security, Supply chain pass did not run, so this is not a clean result.

Model summaries

Model output from untrusted input. Check it before you act on it. Verified means only that the quoted text is at that place. It does not mean the claim is true.

Pass	Status	Model	Summary
Review	❌ failed		No summary. Reason: authentication failed
Security	❌ failed		No summary. Reason: authentication failed
Supply chain	❌ failed		No summary. Reason: authentication failed

Token usage

Pass	Input	Output	Cache write	Cache read	Attempts
Review	not recorded	not recorded	not recorded	not recorded	not recorded
Security	not recorded	not recorded	not recorded	not recorded	not recorded
Supply chain	not recorded	not recorded	not recorded	not recorded	not recorded
Recorded total	not recorded	not recorded	not recorded	not recorded	not recorded